Skip to content

Up to 75% Off Flash Savings

Thinking Putty®
Slime Charmers®
Pinchies®
All Products

Thinking Putty®
Slime Charmers®
Pinchies®
All Products

Search

Item added to your cart

View cart

Collection: Thinking Putty®

Sort by:

181 products

Filter:

Availability (0)

Availability

In stock (181 products)
Out of stock (0 products)

Price

The highest price is $100.00

$

From

To

Filter and sort Filter

Filter and sort

Filter

181 products

Availability

In stock (181 products)
Out of stock (0 products)

Clear

Price

The highest price is $100.00

$

From

$

To

Clear

Sort by:

Remove all

181 products

Best Sellers

Better Butter | Trendsetters - US 1234

Sale

Better Butter | Trendsetters - US 1234

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Eternal Flame | MINI - US 9877

Sale

Eternal Flame | MINI - US 9877

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Buttercream Better Butter | Trendsetters - US 6550

Sale

Buttercream Better Butter | Trendsetters - US 6550

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Mega Watt | MINI - US 9385

Sale

Mega Watt | MINI - US 9385

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Starfish | MINI Tin - US 6749

Sale

Starfish | MINI Tin - US 6749

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale

Better Butter | Trendsetters - US 1234

Sale

Better Butter | Trendsetters - US 1234

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Eternal Flame | MINI - US 9877

Sale

Eternal Flame | MINI - US 9877

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Buttercream Better Butter | Trendsetters - US 6550

Sale

Buttercream Better Butter | Trendsetters - US 6550

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Mega Watt | MINI - US 9385

Sale

Mega Watt | MINI - US 9385

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Starfish | MINI Tin - US 6749

Sale

Starfish | MINI Tin - US 6749

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Scoopberry | SCENTsory™ - US 9017

Sale

Scoopberry | SCENTsory™ - US 9017

Regular price $2.00

Regular price ~~$8.00~~ Sale price $2.00

Sale
Mystic Crystal | MINI - US 3790

Sale

Mystic Crystal | MINI - US 3790

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Evergreen | MINI - US 5526

Sale

Evergreen | MINI - US 5526

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Intergalactic | Hypercolor® - US 2935

Sale

Intergalactic | Hypercolor® - US 2935

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Honey Hive® | Thinking Putty® - US 2850

Sale

Honey Hive® | Thinking Putty® - US 2850

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Fresh Grass | MINI - US 8269

Sale

Fresh Grass | MINI - US 8269

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Falling Water | Liquid Glass® - US 7578

Sale

Falling Water | Liquid Glass® - US 7578

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Avocado | MINI - US 8953

Sale

Avocado | MINI - US 8953

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Gumballer | SCENTsory™ - US 5020

Sale

Gumballer | SCENTsory™ - US 5020

Regular price $2.00

Regular price ~~$8.00~~ Sale price $2.00

Sale
Fairy Sprinkles | MINI - US 2873

Sale

Fairy Sprinkles | MINI - US 2873

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Strange Attractor | Magnetic - US 6975

Sale

Strange Attractor | Magnetic - US 6975

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Enchanting Unicorn | Glowbrights® - US 9882

Sale

Enchanting Unicorn | Glowbrights® - US 9882

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Tidal Wave | Magnetic - US 8805

Sale

Tidal Wave | Magnetic - US 8805

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale
Daydream | MINI - US 8453

Sale

Daydream | MINI - US 8453

Regular price $2.80

Regular price ~~$4.00~~ Sale price $2.80

Sale
Liquid Glass | Liquid Glass® - US 4850

Sale

Liquid Glass | Liquid Glass® - US 4850

Regular price $3.75

Regular price ~~$15.00~~ Sale price $3.75

Sale

1
…
7
8
9
10

Orders and Support

About US
Order Cancellation Policy
Return & Refund Policy

Shopping Details

Orders
Payment Methods
Shipping Policy

Privacy and Terms

Privacy Policy
Cookies Policy
Terms of Service

Contact Information

Email: support@crazyaaronscloseout.com

Phone: 4046553895

Address: 265 Maple Ave Glenside, Pennsylvania 19038 United States

Support Hours: Monday to Friday, 09:00 – 18:00 (Local Time).
Enquiries received outside these hours or on public holidays will be responded to on the next business day.

© 2026 My Store. All rights reserved.

Facebook
Instagram
YouTube
TikTok
X (Twitter)
Pinterest
Snapchat

Payment methods

Choosing a selection results in a full page refresh.
Opens in a new window.

Cookies

We use cookies to improve your experience. You can manage your choices or read our privacy policy for more information.

Cookie preferences

Choose which optional cookies this store can use. You can update your preferences later if the store provides a cookie settings link.

Strictly necessary cookies

Required for core store features such as cart, checkout, account access, and security. These cookies cannot be turned off.

Always on

Preferences cookies Help remember choices such as language, region, currency, and display preferences. Analytics cookies Help us understand how visitors interact with the store so we can improve pages, products, and performance. Marketing cookies Help personalize ads and marketing messages based on your interests and shopping activity.